Audiomidi.app

MP3 to MIDI · Listening and editing guide

Is your converted MIDI shifted or drifting?

Compare a clear note near the start and another near the end. If both are late by the same amount, move the MIDI clip as a unit. If the gap grows, check tempo, stretch settings and later note positions before moving individual notes.

Open the MP3 to MIDI converter

Try three files with the same four pitches

We built three MIDI clips at 120 BPM with the pitches C4, E4, G4 and C5, then reopened each exported file and read its note start times. All three use quarter-second notes with the same velocity. Only their starts change. This is a controlled editing exercise. It does not measure the transcription accuracy of any converter.

Four note starts in each of the reference, fixed shift and growing drift clipsReferenceFixed shiftGrowing drift0 ms2,500 ms
Dots mark the measured starts. In the last row the first dot lines up, but the later dots pull away.
Start times read from the exported MIDI files, in milliseconds
NoteReferenceFixed shiftGrowing drift
C4500750500
E4100012501125
G4150017501750
C5200022502375

What each comparison tells you

In the fixed-shift file, the first note is 250 ms late and the fourth is also 250 ms late. Move the whole clip earlier by 250 ms and all four starts align. If you move only the first note, the three remaining starts stay late.

In the drift file, the first note is on time and the fourth is 375 ms late. The gaps between successive notes are 625 ms instead of 500 ms. Shifting the whole clip earlier by 375 ms would align the last note but make the first note 375 ms early. That calls for checking the clip’s timing scale or tempo interpretation, then comparing the middle notes.

Apply the check to your recording

  1. Import the original audio and MIDI on separate tracks. Choose a sound for the MIDI and keep the original audio audible.
  2. Pick two clear attacks of the same musical part, one early and one late. Compare each attack with the corresponding MIDI note start using the timeline in seconds.
  3. Measure a third point in the middle. If the offsets vary irregularly, inspect the notes there for missed attacks, extra notes or expressive timing before applying a global fix.

Should I quantize first?

Check the offset first. Quantization moves individual starts toward a grid. If a clip starts late, snapping its notes can hide the shared shift while also changing the original spacing. Keep a copy of the unedited export and listen against the recording after each adjustment.